Meet Sarah

Sarah Smith is a dedicated real estate professional who brings a strong work ethic, extensive local expertise, and a proven track record of sales success to every transaction.

Joining RE/MAX Island Realty in 2016, Sarah immediately made an impact by earning Rookie of the Year honors with over $4.5 million in sales in her first 12 months. Since that breakout year, she has built a reputation for high-level negotiation, exceptional client care, and a results-driven approach. Powered by the global reach of RE/MAX and her custom, high-touch marketing strategies, Sarah consistently delivers top-tier results for buyers and sellers across the Hilton Head Island market.  She proudly transacted nearly $30 Million in real estate in 2025 but prides herself on still being able to work personally with each and every client.

Sarah began her Lowcountry career in hospitality and community leadership as the Director of Member Services at Wexford Plantation. Over her five-year tenure, Sarah worked closely with top regional realtors to market and elevate the prestigious private community, an experience that seamlessly sparked her transition into full-time real estate.

Sarah holds an undergraduate degree from Lynchburg College where she competed as a four-year collegiate tennis athlete. She earned her master’s degree in education from the University of South Carolina, Beaufort. Her deep-rooted connection to Hilton Head began during childhood family visits in the early 1990s, giving her an intimate knowledge of the island’s unique neighborhoods, lifestyle, and property values.

Residing in Jarvis Creek Club, Sarah is married to her husband, Alex and has two children, Landon and Harper. Sarah is passionately invested in the growth and community of the place she proudly calls home.

Community Involvement and Support

Sarah is involved at Hilton Head Preparatory where here children go to school and acts as the Dolphin Athletic Club Volunteer Coordinator and Upper School Sports Team representative. She is also involved in the Women’s Association of Hilton Head Island and a supporter of The Celebration Projects, a non-profit that gives birthday parties to deserving children in need.

Sarah is passionate about the Hilton Head Island community!

Awards & Recognition

2017 - 100% Club 

2018- Platinum Club

2019 - Platinum Club

2020- Platinum Club and RE/MAX Hall of Fame

2021 - Platinum Club

2022 - Chairmans Club (7th place commissions earned individual South Carolina for RE/MAX)

2023 - Chairmans Club

2024 - Chairmans Club, 5th place commissions earned individual South Carolina for RE/MAX AND RE/MAX Lifetime Achievement Award

2025 - Chairmans Club (4th place commissions earned individual South Carolina for RE/MAX) AND RealTrends Verified #49 in the state for 2025

Happy Buyers and Sellers

Sarah was incredible & we worked with her long distance and we had never met prior to working with her! She came highly recommended from another realtor and we are so thankful for that! Sarah was a gem to work with from beginning to end! We highly recommend Sarah!! -Shauna: single family home buyer 2026 in Hardeeville, SC

I couldn’t be happier with my experience working with Sarah Smith as my realtor. From start to finish, she was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly responsive. She took the time to truly understand my needs, provided honest advice, and guided me through every step of the process with confidence and care. What really set her apart was her attention to detail and commitment to making sure everything went smoothly. I was in the process of purchasing a new construction home as I was selling my current home and many challenges came up. Even though Sarah was not assisting with the purchase of the new home, she did not hesitate to call the realtor/builder to make sure everyone was on the same page with closing dates etc. Sarah worked around my schedule for showings and would even come and walk my dog when I could not leave work during a showing. I always felt informed, supported, and in great hands. She recommended movers and even came to visit me in my new home to ensure I was settled and happy. If you’re looking for someone who genuinely puts their clients first and delivers outstanding results, I cannot recommend Sarah enough! -Ashley, Bluffton home buyer 2026

Sarah came into selling my home with open arms. She was so generous to pick up the pieces after someone just let my house sit there for many months! She sold my house within weeks (after it being on the market for over 9 months!). She never gave up and she did anything and everything she could to get my house sold!! I would recommend her OVER and OVER! She is friendly, kind, understanding, professional and just a genuine person!! Definitely use her if you are ever looking to buy or sell- you will NOT regret it!!! -Tracy, home seller in 2025

Sarah did an excellent job. We sold and bought homes using Sarah’s expertise. She is trustworthy, honest and reliable. I would highly recommend her. She rates a 10 from us! - John, Indigo Run Hilton Head buyer and seller, 2026

“Sarah was outstanding from start to finish. We contacted her based on a recommendation from another couple who had used her as their realtor and were very satisfied—and they were absolutely right. Sarah communicated with us consistently through emails, texts, and phone calls, keeping us informed every step of the way. She took the time to clearly explain the process and walk us through each stage as it came up. She also did an excellent job balancing the work at hand while proactively preparing us for what was next. Most importantly, she made it clear that she was always available, whether early in the morning or well after dinner. I couldn’t recommend her more highly. - Brad, Hilton Head Plantation home buyer and seller, 2026

Sara did an outstanding job in helping us find our home. She went above and beyond for us, absolutely the best! Highly recommend her as your next realtor! -John, Indigo Run Hilton Head Island seller and buyer, 2026

Read more reviews!

Visit Zillow to see hundreds of 5 star reviews from happy clients who have worked with Sarah!